Contents
Steel vs Stainless Steel: A Head-to-Toes Comparison
- John
What Is the Essential Difference Between Steel and Stainless Steel?
Steel is an iron-based alloy, primarily composed of iron and a small amount of carbon. Different types and steel grades have different properties depending on the other alloying elements they contain, such as manganese, silicon, and chromium.
All steel contains iron and carbon, and so does stainless steel. However, only steel with at least 10.5% chromium can be called stainless steel. Chromium is the key element that helps prevent rusting in stainless steel.
Chemical Composition of Steel vs Stainless Steel
Steel is mainly composed of iron (Fe) with carbon (C) content ranging from 0.02% – 2%. Common alloying elements include:
- manganese (Mn)
- silicon (Si)
- sulfur (S)
- phosphorus (P)
*Usually less than 1% each.
Some steels also have additions of chromium (Cr), nickel (Ni), molybdenum (Mo), and vanadium (V) to enhance specific properties.
Stainless steel is an alloy of iron with 10.5% – 30% chromium (Cr) and 0.03% – 1% carbon (C). Common alloying elements include nickel (Ni), molybdenum (Mo), and sometimes titanium (Ti) and nitrogen (N) to improve strength and corrosion resistance.
Properties of Steel vs Stainless Steel
Let’s take a comparison of key properties between steel and stainless steel:
Corrosion Resistance
- Steel rusts easily when exposed to moisture; protective coatings or treatments are required to prevent rust.
- Stainless steel is more corrosion-resistant due to alloying elements like chromium and nickel.
Heat Resistance
- Stainless steel typically has better heat resistance due to its chromium oxide layer, *but not all grades are equal—grades like austenitic stainless steel perform better at higher temperatures.
- Some steels with added chromium or molybdenum can also resist heat well.
Strength
- Steel typically has higher initial strength than austenitic stainless steel due to its higher carbon content.
- In contrast, stainless steel contains added alloying elements such as chromium and nickel, which can slightly reduce its overall strength.
- *Certain stainless steel grades, such as martensitic or heat-treated varieties, can achieve strength equal to or greater than regular steel.
Hardness
- Steel is generally harder than most stainless steel due to its higher carbon content. This increased carbon makes steel stronger, more wear-resistant, and durable, giving it an advantage in stainless steel hardness and making it suitable for cutting tools and heavy machinery.
Ductility
- Stainless steel, especially austenitic grades, is generally more malleable than steel.
- *Steel’s ductility varies with carbon content and alloying elements, with low-carbon steel being more malleable than high-carbon steel.
Toughness
- Steel is more brittle because of more carbon, especially at lower temperatures.
- Stainless steel, especially grades with nickel, retains toughness better at a wider range of temperatures.
Magnetic Properties
- Steel is magnetic.
- Most stainless steel is non-magnetic, except for specific types and grades. 300 series contain chromium and nickel, which makes them austenitic and generally non-magnetic. 400 series contain only chromium, which makes them martensitic or ferritic, hence magnetic.
- *Most stainless steels in use are austenitic, which is non-magnetic. However, they can become slightly magnetic under certain conditions, such as cold working.
Appearance
- Steel is usually dull gray and can rust or change color when exposed to moisture.
- Stainless steel has a shiny or brushed look and does not rust, keeping its appearance for a long time.
Manufacturing Processes of Steel vs Stainless Steel
Although steel and stainless steel share similar manufacturing processes, we are here to discuss some of their key differences.
Manufacturing of Steel
Steel is produced by melting raw materials like iron ore, coal (as coke), and limestone in a blast furnace. This process reduces iron ore to molten iron by removing oxygen.
The molten iron is then refined to lower the carbon content and eliminate some impurities. After refining, the steel is cast into shapes and rolled into products like sheets or beams.
The overall process is straightforward and doesn’t require extensive purification.
Manufacturing of Stainless Steel
Stainless steel follows a similar basic process but with stricter controls and additional steps to achieve higher purity and specific properties.
- Precise Melting in an Electric Furnace
Stainless steel is melted in an electric furnace rather than a blast furnace. The electric furnace allows precise temperature control, which is crucial when adding alloying elements like chromium and nickel. These elements give stainless steel its corrosion-resistant properties. - Additional Refining Steps
To ensure high purity, stainless steel undergoes extra refining processes:- Degassing
Removing gases like hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen from the molten steel. These gases can cause weaknesses and make the steel brittle if not removed. - Desulfurization and Dephosphorization
Eliminating sulfur and phosphorus can reduce toughness and make the steel more prone to cracking. Removing these impurities enhances strength and corrosion resistance.
- Degassing
- Controlled Alloying
Precise amounts of alloying elements are added to achieve the desired grade of stainless steel. Accurate composition is essential for its performance and durability. - Heat Treatment
Stainless steel often undergoes heat treatments like annealing to relieve internal stresses and improve ductility. Such treatments are more common in stainless steel production than in regular steel. - Enhanced Surface Finishing
Because stainless steel is frequently used in applications where appearance matters—like kitchen appliances and medical instruments—it undergoes additional finishing processes. These may include polishing and passivation to improve surface quality and enhance corrosion resistance.
Summarizing Key Differences
Stainless steel manufacturing involves stricter processes to achieve higher purity and specific properties:
- Controlled Melting: Using electric furnaces for precise temperature control.
- Extra Refining: Degassing, desulfurization, and dephosphorization are performed to remove impurities that affect corrosion resistance and strength.
- Exact Alloying: Adding precise amounts of elements to attain desired characteristics.
- Enhanced Treatments: Applying heat treatments and surface finishing to improve performance and appearance.
Processing Characteristics of Steel vs Stainless Steel
Weldability
Steel is easier to weld than stainless steel because of its lower carbon content and fewer alloying elements, making it more forgiving during welding.
Stainless steel contains higher chromium and alloying elements and is more prone to warping, cracking, or corrosion if welding is not handled properly.
| Welding Process | Steel | Stainless Steel |
| Welding Method | Common: MIG, TIG, SMAW | Preferred: TIG, Laser, MIG |
| Filler Material | Carbon steel or low alloy filler rods | Stainless steel filler wire (e.g., 308, 316) |
| Preheat and Post-heat Treatment | Preheat and post-heat often required to prevent cracking | Usually no preheat needed, post-weld annealing may be necessary for some grades |
| Thermal Deformation Control | Lower sensitivity to thermal distortion | High control of heat input to prevent distortion and intergranular corrosion |
Machinability
Steel is generally easier to machine due to its lower strength and minimal work-hardening properties. Standard machining techniques like turning, drilling, and milling are typically sufficient for steel.
In contrast, stainless steel is stronger and tends to work-harden quickly, making it more challenging to machine. Specialized techniques and tooling are often required for stainless steel, such as face milling and high-speed drilling.
Hardenability
Steel typically has higher hardenability than stainless steel, meaning it can become uniformly hard throughout its thickness when heat-treated. This is due to its carbon content and alloying elements that promote hardening.
Stainless steel‘s ability to harden depends on its type. Martensitic stainless steels can be hardened by heat treatment, while austenitic stainless steels cannot and are usually strengthened through cold working. Overall, steel is generally easier to harden than most stainless steel.
Applications of Steel vs Stainless Steel
Steel is often used in industries where strength and durability are key. Its ability to handle heavy loads and its affordability make it a popular choice. You’ll find it in construction, automotive, and manufacturing, appearing in buildings, vehicles, and industrial machinery.
Stainless steel is preferred in environments where corrosion resistance is important. Its non-toxic and easy-to-clean properties make it ideal for food production, healthcare, and consumer goods. You’ll commonly see it in kitchenware, medical instruments, and even decorative items.
Cost Differences of Steel vs Stainless Steel
Steel is generally cheaper than stainless steel because of the reasons listed below.
Raw Material Cost
- Steel is primarily made of iron and carbon, which is inexpensive. Other alloying elements in steel vary by grade but generally have lower amounts.
- Stainless steel contains more alloying elements, primarily high amounts of chromium, sometimes nickel or molybdenum. This makes it more expensive than steel.
Manufacturing Cost
- Stainless steel manufacturing involves more complex processes, such as precision melting, casting, alloying, advanced heat treatment, surface finishing, etc. This increases time, labor, and energy costs.
- Stainless steel is harder to machine and fabricate because it is more rigid. Special tools and techniques are required. Final products are hence more pricey.
Maintenance and Care of Steel vs Stainless Steel
Stainless steel’s smoother surface and corrosion resistance make it need less and simpler maintenance and care. Let’s take a closer look at how they differ.
Rust and Corrosion Protection
- Steel: Prone to rust and requires regular rust-proofing (e.g., oil, paint, galvanization).
- Stainless steel: More resistant to rust but still needs occasional cleaning in tough environments (like near the sea or in acidic areas) to prevent rust.
Cleaning and Surface Maintenance
- Steel: Needs frequent cleaning to remove dust and moisture and may need sanding or repainting to maintain its appearance.
- Stainless Steel: Needs less cleaning, and simple care like light polishing or using special cleaners can restore its shine.
Adaptability to Environment
- Steel: Easily damaged in humid or corrosive environments, requiring frequent protection and maintenance.
- Stainless Steel: Better suited for harsh environments but still needs periodic maintenance in extreme conditions.
Lifespan
- Steel: Lifespan is extended through regular rust prevention and surface maintenance.
- Stainless Steel: Lifespan is extended by keeping it clean and avoiding contact with corrosive substances, requiring less intensive care.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Steel vs Stainless Steel
Let’s finish by taking a simple, quick overview of their advantages and disadvantages:
Advantages and Disadvantages of Steel
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
| Strong and durable, suitable for heavy-duty applications. | Prone to rust and corrosion. |
| Affordable and widely available. | Requires regular maintenance to prevent rust. |
| High tensile strength, ideal for construction. | Heavy, which can limit mobility in some uses. |
| Easy to weld and mold into shapes. | Conducts heat and electricity, posing potential hazards. |
| Versatile, used in a wide range of industries. | Less resistant to chemical exposure. |
Advantages and Disadvantages of Stainless Steel
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
| Resistant to rust and corrosion, enhancing durability. | More expensive than carbon steel. |
| Sleek appearance, preferred in design and architecture. | Not as strong as steel in some applications. |
| Low maintenance, long-lasting material. | Difficult to mold or work with compared to carbon steel. |
| Non-reactive to many chemicals, ideal for medical and food use. | Harder to weld due to its properties. |
| Tough, can be melted down and reused without losing properties. | Prone to work hardening, making fabrication challenging. |
What You Might Also Concern
Is stainless steel lighter than steel?
No, stainless steel is not lighter than regular steel; they have similar densities. However, stainless steel contains additional elements like chromium and nickel, which can slightly increase its weight.
Is stainless steel better than steel for cooking?
es, stainless steel is generally better than regular steel for cooking because it is resistant to rust, corrosion, and staining. It is also non-reactive, meaning it won’t affect the taste of acidic foods, and it’s easier to clean, making it a popular choice for cookware.
Which is better for jewelry, steel or stainless steel?
Stainless steel is better for jewelry because it resists rust, tarnish, and corrosion, making it more durable and low-maintenance than regular steel.
Which is better, mild steel or stainless steel?
Stainless steel is generally better than mild steel because it’s more corrosion-resistant, stronger, and lasts longer. However, mild steel is cheaper and easier to work with for non-corrosive environments. The choice depends on the specific use case.
Summary & Furthermore
This article discusses the key differences between steel and stainless steel, including composition, properties, manufacturing processes, processing characteristics, applications, costs, and other important aspects. To learn more about steel, stainless steel, or other steel types, check out our blog or contact our metal experts.
As a leading manufacturer and solutions provider of specialty steel, we deliver multi-industry application solutions and customized services with a 100% quality guarantee, committed to growing together with our customers. Visit our website to learn more, or send us a quote, and we will contact you shortly!
